July 31, 2004
#94 - Research So Bad He May as Well Make It up

Cuban prostitutes have received an unwelcome compliment from President Bush courtesy of an Internet search gone wrong.

Earlier this month, Bush launched an attack against Fidel Castro and his alleged promotion of sex tourism in Cuba. Our fearless leader dug way back to a 1992 speech given by Castro to prove his case.

"The dictator welcomes sex tourism," Bush told a room of law enforcement officials in Florida, according to the Los Angeles Times. "Here's how he bragged about the industry," Bush said. "This is his quote: 'Cuba has the cleanest and most educated prostitutes in the world.'"

As it turns out, Bush had lifted that quotation not from an actual Castro speech but rather from a 2001 essay written by then Dartmouth University undergraduate Charles Trumbull. In the essay, Trumbull did appear to quote a Castro speech about prostitution. Sadly, the student made the quotation up.

According to officials, the actual quotation from Castro's 1992 speech reads as follows: "There are hookers, but prostitution is not allowed in our country. There are no women forced to sell themselves to a man, to a foreigner, to a tourist. Those who do so do it on their own, voluntarily…. We can say that they are highly educated hookers and quite healthy, because we are the country with the lowest number of AIDS cases."

Castro admitted that prostitution does exist in Cuba, as it does here, but tried to defuse the matter by pointing to the country's high health and education standards. This is hardly "welcoming sex tourism" as Bush claims.

And this isn't the first time the Internet has baffled Bush. Back in 2003, the President cited another student's thesis when making a case to go to war. The student's work ended up in a government document describing Iraq's weapons capability. Not exactly the kind of hard intelligence needed to justify an attack on another country.

But just as the Bush administration did with the Iraq evidence, it is not backing down about being wrong on the Castro issue.

"The president's point in citing Castro's quote was to highlight Castro's morally corrupt attitude to human trafficking," White House spokeswoman Claire Buchan told the LA Times.

How funny then that the quotation ended up pointing out how inept the Bush administration is at research. Surely, the White House is committed to improving its information gathering practices in the future? Well, no. Bush's speech "was vetted the same way all the president's speeches are vetted," Buchan told the paper. (The Register, via Helpful Reader Eric)

Comments

What an idiot this guy is! I think your website is excellent. I'm validating more and more why I already knew he was such a bufoon and probably the biggest mistake this country has ever seen or known. I don't know how far reaching and to what extent he'll end up putting us in danger and taking away what our forefathers fought so hard to ensure for the rest of us - but I do know that so far, it's bad enough already and I'm more afraid everyday..afraid of him, Cheney and what other diabolical schemes they'll saturate the minds of millions of apparently brainless Americans. Which is perhaps the most frightening aspect of all of this...all of the people who back him up no matter how much evidence and proof there is that he has bald-faced lied to them over and over and used and abused their dogged devotion worse than any others. His overly passionate supporters should be the ones angriest at him for taking their devotion and allegiance and using it to fuel his own agenda and avarice. But - doh! No - they're too darned stupid and stubborn to want to admit that they've been used like an old shoe. Keep up the great work.

Posted by: Monica Parker on August 7, 2004 11:02 PM

This man is SHAMELESS!!! Why can,t the American people see thru these LIES?????????????????

Posted by: Claire Turner on October 29, 2004 02:03 PM

"Bad Leaders are elected by good people who don't vote" .... & ..... "The population keep increasing but intelligence remains a constant"

Posted by: Steve on November 4, 2004 02:53 AM