June 26, 2003
#494 - His Smallpox Vaccination Program: Miserable Failure, or Manipulative Hype?

Back in December, Dubya made a big hairy deal about smallpox vaccinations for military personnel and emergency response teams among medical professionals:

We believe that regimes hostile to the United States may possess this dangerous virus. To protect our citizens in the aftermath of September the 11th, we are evaluating old threats in a new light. Our government has no information that a smallpox attack is imminent. Yet it is prudent to prepare for the possibility that terrorists would kill indiscriminately -- who kill indiscriminately would use diseases as a weapon.

George even got one himself, reminding us that he was ready to step up to his obligation as Commander-in-Chief.

The part of the plan that called for the inoculation of 500,000 military personnel proceeded without much fuss. The planned inoculation of 500,000 first responder healthcare workers is a different story.

Many were concerned that the risks associated with the vaccine weren’t adequately justified; others refused to be vaccinated without a pre-established compensation fund for those who suffered ill effects (the Bush administration’s initial response: workers’ comp can cover it, or you can sue the federal government for negligence). Ultimately, Bush signed a compensation plan, but in the meantime local governments struggled with the costs associated with the program and a shortage of federal funds.

As of the beginning of June - with the program in place for five months - 36,217 healthcare workers had been vaccinated.

A quarter of those are in Florida, Texas, and Tennessee.

So we have two possibilities here:

1) The inoculations are necessary for the safety of the American people, in which case the Bush administration has failed to carry out a vital program, or

2) The inoculations aren’t necessary, and Bush values fear-mongering, manipulative hype more than the health of American citizens.

Guess which one we’d pick.

Comments